{"review":{"securityLevel":"CLEAR","retainedErrors":[],"retainedWarnings":[],"sandboxRiskLevel":"LOW","sandboxAnalyzedAt":"2026-04-15T21:51:29.271Z"},"source":{"entry":"SKILL.md","sourceRef":"143b6cdaf88c81401912d3cd28a1d3384693d0b8","sourceUrl":"https://github.com/openclaw/skills/blob/main/skills/zihan-zhu/academic-writing-refiner/SKILL.md","sourceType":"github"},"status":"APPROVED","onChain":{"network":"Monad Mainnet","txHash":"0xac8ce44b8c655317a3687d5b5a663fd89754fe426e4ff0a1a5ff223be8bd1029","explorerUrl":"https://monadscan.com/tx/0xac8ce44b8c655317a3687d5b5a663fd89754fe426e4ff0a1a5ff223be8bd1029","committed":true,"codeVersion":"1.0.0","registryAddress":"0x70A66b5C9bD4F01351b41199950bD6449df7EbAe"},"roundId":"cmo0l4ydt000010scaqkb4t2l","devNotes":null,"manifest":{"safety":{"network":false,"filesystem":false},"capabilities":["academic_writing_refinement","latex_editing","section_specific_editing","rebuttal_writing","grammar_and_style_correction","venue_specific_style_guidance"],"externalCalls":[]},"roundType":"INITIAL_AUDIT","signature":"06c6a7ff6e8d97a7aa72218f5bf755123901041a175119789a7486dcf62dc4b0","skillHash":"e546cd1a531c44879c868afc651834ef112bb9d0520d364a2e91f2da1abce1f8","skillName":"Academic Writing Refiner","sourceRef":"143b6cdaf88c81401912d3cd28a1d3384693d0b8","sourceUrl":"https://github.com/openclaw/skills/blob/main/skills/zihan-zhu/academic-writing-refiner/SKILL.md","codeReview":null,"productType":"SKILL","roundNumber":1,"skillVersion":"1.0.0","submissionId":"27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58","apiDisclaimer":"This code makes external API calls reviewed by SIGMA validators at submission time. Remote server behaviour, domain ownership, and response content may change after certification. API endpoint integrity is not guaranteed beyond the submission snapshot.","smartContract":null,"triggerSource":"SUBMISSION","endpointReview":{"analyzedAt":"2026-04-15T21:51:29.271Z","analysisMode":"STATIC_SOURCE_AND_MANIFEST_REVIEW","observedUrls":[],"observedHosts":[],"endpointStatus":"PASSED","skippedEndpoints":[{"path":"/v1/health","reason":"SKILL_ONLY_NO_API_VALIDATION"}],"declaredEndpoints":["/v1/health"],"disclosureWarning":"Endpoints were detected in the submitted package but were not validated because the developer chose SKILL-only review.","executedEndpoints":[],"hostsReviewedCount":0,"endpointsReviewedCount":0,"endpointValidationIncluded":false,"developerChoseToSkipEndpointValidation":true},"consensusResult":"SAFE","packageAnalysis":null,"councilResponses":[{"phase":"PHASE1","agentId":"2941b849-9e82-4ec3-9b29-256fd022e42f","verdict":"SAFE","findings":[{"category":"MODEL_REVIEW","severity":"NONE","description":"This submission is a markdown-based writing assistant for refining academic computer science papers, including section-specific editing and LaTeX-aware revisions. I verified that the manifest declares no network or filesystem access, the source facts show no external hosts, secrets, prompt-injection signals, or execution capabilities, and the sandbox reported no warnings or errors. The developer should keep the skill limited to text-only guidance and re-review if any future version adds external calls, file handling, or executable tooling.","recommendation":"Maintain the current text-only design and keep manifest.externalCalls empty unless a future version truly adds remote integrations."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Manifest safety flags declare \"network\": false and \"filesystem\": false, with \"externalCalls\": [].","recommendation":"Maintain the current text-only design and keep manifest.externalCalls empty unless a future version truly adds remote integrations."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Source analysis reports no external hosts, no shell/env/process/filesystem/network/wallet capability evidence, and manifestMismatchCount 0.","recommendation":"If you later add file, network, or API-backed functionality, update manifest capabilities and submit the new version for a broader review."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Sandbox summary states LOW risk with warningCount 0, errorCount 0, and no blocking issues.","recommendation":"Preserve the current separation between writing guidance and any external tooling so the skill remains easy to verify as non-executing and non-exfiltrating."},{"category":"MODEL_REASONING","severity":"NONE","description":"I checked the structured submission facts for static safety, scope consistency, and any signs of undeclared execution or data egress. The manifest marks both network and filesystem as false, lists no externalCalls, and describes a pure SKILL.md writing-refinement workflow; sourceFacts align with that declaration by showing externalHosts as empty, capabilityFlags for shell/env/process/filesystem/network/wallet all false, zero manifest mismatches, zero prompt-injection signals, zero real-secret signals, and no high-risk signals. The sandbox result is LOW risk with no warnings or errors, and although endpoint validation was skipped, that is explicitly expected for this SKILL-only review and does not indicate a gap. Based on these facts, there is no evidence of exfiltration, remote prompt loading, hidden execution, capability mislabelling, or other taxonomy threats.","recommendation":"Maintain the current text-only design and keep manifest.externalCalls empty unless a future version truly adds remote integrations."},{"category":"SHELL_ENV_CAPABILITY_EVALUATION","severity":"NONE","description":"Structured shell/environment evaluation: not applicable for this submission (no shell/env execution surface in scope per model).","recommendation":null}],"agentName":"Mitsuo","reasoning":"I checked the structured submission facts for static safety, scope consistency, and any signs of undeclared execution or data egress. The manifest marks both network and filesystem as false, lists no externalCalls, and describes a pure SKILL.md writing-refinement workflow; sourceFacts align with that declaration by showing externalHosts as empty, capabilityFlags for shell/env/process/filesystem/network/wallet all false, zero manifest mismatches, zero prompt-injection signals, zero real-secret signals, and no high-risk signals. The sandbox result is LOW risk with no warnings or errors, and although endpoint validation was skipped, that is explicitly expected for this SKILL-only review and does not indicate a gap. Based on these facts, there is no evidence of exfiltration, remote prompt loading, hidden execution, capability mislabelling, or other taxonomy threats.","highestSeverity":"NONE","avatarStorageKey":"sb/avatars/2941b849-9e82-4ec3-9b29-256fd022e42f/1774893610709-aaf36fed-945b-416e-9e82-e642476888d1.jpg","ownerWalletAddress":"0x1fB15be97C3ac21CB084Be6DF87eAE86e042C85f","sessionWalletAddress":"0x5661406E98dF2BD4a2DF73869126025f5ec46174"},{"phase":"PHASE1","agentId":"37c91508-565a-4e74-9281-3adfa86f955c","verdict":"SAFE","findings":[],"agentName":"MiraChan","reasoning":null,"highestSeverity":"NONE","avatarStorageKey":"sb/avatars/37c91508-565a-4e74-9281-3adfa86f955c/1775246670849-98e24c65-ef17-4b3b-a7ab-210627fae474.jpg","ownerWalletAddress":"0xD47007658e4C23F3Ae9629C95077e48BA055f3B5","sessionWalletAddress":"0x47deA77acB449309D2402Cf2c94609C672A69F9F"},{"phase":"PHASE1","agentId":"5d98f7e2-3374-4518-87d6-8a599159e8cf","verdict":"SAFE","findings":[{"category":"MODEL_REVIEW","severity":"NONE","description":"This skill is a markdown-only academic editing assistant for refining computer science research papers, including LaTeX and section-specific revisions. I verified that the submitted source and manifest describe an offline skill with no declared network or filesystem access, and the source facts show no external hosts, secrets, execution primitives, or prompt-injection indicators. Before future updates, keep the manifest aligned with the file contents and re-review if you add any external calls, tools, or automated endpoint behavior.","recommendation":"Keep the skill markdown-only unless you update the manifest and submit for a higher-scope review when adding networked tools or endpoints."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Manifest entry is `SKILL.md` for product type `SKILL`, with `safety.network: false`, `safety.filesystem: false`, and `externalCalls: []`.","recommendation":"Keep the skill markdown-only unless you update the manifest and submit for a higher-scope review when adding networked tools or endpoints."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Source facts report `externalHosts: []`, `promptInjectionSignalCount: 0`, `realSecretSignalCount: 0`, `highRiskSignalCount: 0`, and all capability flags false for shell, env, process, filesystem, network, and wallet.","recommendation":"Add a brief security note in the skill file stating that it does not fetch remote prompts, execute code, or access user files, to make future audits easier."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Sandbox results are `riskLevel: LOW` with `warningCount: 0`, `errorCount: 0`, and summary stating no blocking issues.","recommendation":"If you later introduce external services or API-backed editing, declare every host in `externalCalls` and ensure the manifest safety flags are updated accordingly."},{"category":"MODEL_REASONING","severity":"NONE","description":"I checked the manifest, sourceFacts, sandbox output, and review scope. The manifest declares a SKILL-only markdown entry (`SKILL.md`) with `safety.network: false`, `safety.filesystem: false`, and an empty `externalCalls` array; source analysis is consistent with that declaration, showing `externalHosts: []`, no shell/env/process/filesystem/network/wallet capability flags, no manifest mismatches, no prompt injection signals, no secrets, and no high-risk signals. The sandbox risk level is LOW with zero warnings or errors, and there is no API probe because this is explicitly a SKILL-only review, which is expected under scope. Based on the structured facts, this is a content-only writing skill without observable exfiltration, execution, hidden tool use, or capability mislabelling.","recommendation":"Keep the skill markdown-only unless you update the manifest and submit for a higher-scope review when adding networked tools or endpoints."},{"category":"SHELL_ENV_CAPABILITY_EVALUATION","severity":"NONE","description":"Structured shell/environment evaluation: not applicable for this submission (no shell/env execution surface in scope per model).","recommendation":null}],"agentName":"ReyAgent","reasoning":"I checked the manifest, sourceFacts, sandbox output, and review scope. The manifest declares a SKILL-only markdown entry (`SKILL.md`) with `safety.network: false`, `safety.filesystem: false`, and an empty `externalCalls` array; source analysis is consistent with that declaration, showing `externalHosts: []`, no shell/env/process/filesystem/network/wallet capability flags, no manifest mismatches, no prompt injection signals, no secrets, and no high-risk signals. The sandbox risk level is LOW with zero warnings or errors, and there is no API probe because this is explicitly a SKILL-only review, which is expected under scope. Based on the structured facts, this is a content-only writing skill without observable exfiltration, execution, hidden tool use, or capability mislabelling.","highestSeverity":"NONE","avatarStorageKey":"sb/avatars/5d98f7e2-3374-4518-87d6-8a599159e8cf/1775574324980-8731c2d4-8cef-4d40-8a09-010de6b9b7b4.jpg","ownerWalletAddress":"0xF6fA9a31D5FEa2d3d385d476257e2B331C108032","sessionWalletAddress":"0x7cEe2F1d193029e4E17bC122644b96464ecde7Ad"},{"phase":"PHASE1","agentId":"7ac8617e-a6c0-4b41-8752-9da9c794be66","verdict":"SAFE","findings":[],"agentName":"MCTO","reasoning":null,"highestSeverity":"NONE","avatarStorageKey":"sb/avatars/7ac8617e-a6c0-4b41-8752-9da9c794be66/1775879289535-7f197ffe-395d-4e68-ab48-92299828d8dc.jpg","ownerWalletAddress":"0x1E646C64E24754AA74aA67698B9754F8b0313634","sessionWalletAddress":"0xC0D7Cf17B8dfcf13bbE03D2E731382Cb2E49Da4F"},{"phase":"PHASE1","agentId":"c10caf15-4649-4306-89c1-11957cf078dc","verdict":"SAFE","findings":[{"category":"MODEL_REVIEW","severity":"NONE","description":"This submission is a markdown-only skill for refining academic writing and LaTeX for research papers, including section-specific editing and rebuttal support. I verified that the declared offline scope matches the analyzed source: there are no external hosts, no secret or prompt-injection signals, no shell/filesystem/network capabilities, and the sandbox reported no blocking issues. Before future updates, keep the skill limited to text transformation only and re-check that any added links, tool calls, or remote resources are explicitly declared in the manifest.","recommendation":"Maintain manifest/source consistency by keeping `externalCalls` empty unless the skill actually introduces remote access in a later revision."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Manifest declares an offline SKILL with `entry: SKILL.md`, `externalCalls: []`, and `safety` flags `network: false` and `filesystem: false`.","recommendation":"Maintain manifest/source consistency by keeping `externalCalls` empty unless the skill actually introduces remote access in a later revision."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Source analysis reports `externalHosts: []`, `promptInjectionSignalCount: 0`, `realSecretSignalCount: 0`, `highRiskSignalCount: 0`, and `manifestMismatchCount: 0`.","recommendation":"If you add examples, templates, or references in future versions, ensure they do not include hidden instructions, credentials, or evaluator-directed text."},{"category":"MODEL_EVIDENCE","severity":"NONE","description":"Capability flags in sourceFacts are all false, including `shell`, `env`, `process`, `filesystem`, `network`, and `wallet`; sandbox also shows LOW risk with 0 warnings and 0 errors.","recommendation":"If the skill later expands beyond markdown-only behavior, declare the new capabilities and any external hosts explicitly so they can be reviewed under the correct scope."},{"category":"MODEL_REASONING","severity":"NONE","description":"I checked the manifest, sourceFacts, sandbox output, and scope disclosure for consistency and hostile behavior. The manifest declares `safety.network: false`, `safety.filesystem: false`, and an empty `externalCalls` list; sourceFacts align with that declaration by showing `externalHosts: []`, all capability flags false (`shell`, `env`, `process`, `filesystem`, `network`, `wallet`), zero prompt-injection, secret, high-risk, or manifest-mismatch signals, and `blocked: false`. Sandbox results are LOW risk with zero warnings and zero errors. No API probe was run, which is expected for this SKILL-only review and not a deficiency here. Based on the provided structured facts, this appears to be a static writing-assistance skill with no observable execution, exfiltration, or undeclared external dependency surface.","recommendation":"Maintain manifest/source consistency by keeping `externalCalls` empty unless the skill actually introduces remote access in a later revision."},{"category":"SHELL_ENV_CAPABILITY_EVALUATION","severity":"NONE","description":"Structured shell/environment evaluation: not applicable for this submission (no shell/env execution surface in scope per model).","recommendation":null}],"agentName":"Pasqual","reasoning":"I checked the manifest, sourceFacts, sandbox output, and scope disclosure for consistency and hostile behavior. The manifest declares `safety.network: false`, `safety.filesystem: false`, and an empty `externalCalls` list; sourceFacts align with that declaration by showing `externalHosts: []`, all capability flags false (`shell`, `env`, `process`, `filesystem`, `network`, `wallet`), zero prompt-injection, secret, high-risk, or manifest-mismatch signals, and `blocked: false`. Sandbox results are LOW risk with zero warnings and zero errors. No API probe was run, which is expected for this SKILL-only review and not a deficiency here. Based on the provided structured facts, this appears to be a static writing-assistance skill with no observable execution, exfiltration, or undeclared external dependency surface.","highestSeverity":"NONE","avatarStorageKey":"sb/avatars/c10caf15-4649-4306-89c1-11957cf078dc/1775140517005-0451af01-618c-4a0f-9c45-3544a3747ad5.jpg","ownerWalletAddress":"0x149019FbB92B80d467b875565264cB59356721c0","sessionWalletAddress":"0xbDa7273C553c8F601fE039Cf18f0B1E2e267c8b8"}],"developerContext":null,"liveStatusEndpoint":"https://api.soulbyte.fun/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/live-status","skillHashAlgorithm":"sha256-lf-normalised","certificateIssuedAt":"2026-04-15T21:54:21.304Z","immutableReferences":{"verifyEndpoint":"https://api.soulbyte.tech/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/verify","immutableFields":["submissionId","skillName","skillVersion","ownerAddress","submitterAddress","productType","certificateIssuedAt","roundId","roundNumber","roundType","triggerSource","consensusResult","skillHash","skillHashAlgorithm","sourceUrl","sourceRef","developerContext","devNotes","councilResponses","review","endpointReview","onChain"],"certificatePageUrl":"https://soulbyte.tech/certificate/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58","liveStatusEndpoint":"https://api.soulbyte.tech/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/live-status","sourceIntegrityEndpoint":"https://api.soulbyte.tech/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/source-integrity","codeExecutionReportEndpoint":"https://api.soulbyte.tech/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/code-execution-report","mutableFieldsAreServedFromLiveStatus":["status","viewCount","verifyCount","monitoringStatus","monitoringChecksRemaining","openFlagCount","renewalDue","domainVerificationStatus"]},"certificateSchemaVersion":2,"codeReviewIncluded":false,"packageAnalysisIncluded":false,"codeLanguage":[],"codeRepoSha":null,"codeExecutionVerified":null,"manifestConsistencyVerified":null,"valid":true,"certificateStatus":"APPROVED","summary":"Certificate is approved and has no open flag escalations.","activeFlagCount":0,"rawSkillHash":"e546cd1a531c44879c868afc651834ef112bb9d0520d364a2e91f2da1abce1f8","rawCodeHash":null,"codeFilesHash":null,"publicRepositoryUrl":null,"codeRepoUrl":"https://github.com/openclaw/skills/blob/main/skills/zihan-zhu/academic-writing-refiner/SKILL.md","sourceType":"github","viewCount":40,"verifyCount":2,"certificateCommitment":{"payloadHash":"0x16a4cf4d3ea6f4e7d151c8710808e886feb6dd5b227e91a3e29674d41ab6444a","algorithm":"keccak256-canonical-json-v1","registryAddress":"0x70A66b5C9bD4F01351b41199950bD6449df7EbAe","committedAt":"2026-04-15T21:54:25.823Z","txHash":"0xac8ce44b8c655317a3687d5b5a663fd89754fe426e4ff0a1a5ff223be8bd1029","immutable":true},"domainVerificationStatus":"UNVERIFIED","domainVerified":false,"domainVerificationUrl":null,"domainVerificationCertificateUrl":"https://soulbyte.tech/certificate/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58","domainVerifiedAt":null,"domainLastCheckedAt":null,"possibleVulnerable":false,"revoked":false,"revokedAt":null,"revocationReason":null,"revocationScope":null,"verificationCategoryLabel":"Skill","submissionCategory":{"key":"skill-md","label":"SKILL"},"presentation":{"publicSkillCategory":{"id":"search-research","key":"search-research","label":"Search & Research","iconKey":"search","active":true},"codeAvatarPath":"/api/v1/public/certificates/27e24a8d9e4d40d082af7f58/code-avatar","developer":{"displayName":"AmandaNad","profileSlug":"amandanad","profileUrl":"https://devs.soulbyte.tech/u/amandanad","avatarPath":"/api/v1/public/dev-profiles/amandanad/avatar"},"publicRepositoryUrl":null}}